The SEC Should not Expand or Contract they should Upgrade
With all the talk of the Big Ten expanding there is much talk about what the SEC should do. Most of the talk centers around expansion. Expansion for the SEC would be a mistake. It would be a wiser move to jettison some of the hangers on (looking directly at you Mississippi State, Vanderbilt, and Kentucky). Other than regional proximity Mississippi State, Vanderbilt, and Kentucky bring nothing to the SEC other than Kentucky’s basketball program. So Kentucky gets a reprieve. Kentucky is resonably competitive in football and helps legitimize the SEC in basketball to keep the RPI of the rest of the conference up. Kentucky you get to stay Miss. State and Vanderbilt can join the Big East or Conference USA.
Now that the dead weight has been jettisoned who should the SEC take? The list includes Texas, Oklahoma, Texas A&M, Florida State, Clemson, Miami, Louisville, and South Florida.
Let’s not fool anyone the one school everyone wants is Texas. The Big Ten wants Texas to deliver the Houston, Dallas, and San Antonio markets to the Big Ten network. Texas would enable the SEC to beef up their deals with CBS and ESPN. Texas will deliver a lot of TV sets to the conference that they join. Texas does not come without baggage. Due to political pressure back in the early 90’s the Longhorns had to take Baylor and Texas A&M with them to the new Big 12. Texas A&M would not be a problem Baylor is a problem for the same reason Vanderbilt is a problem. Texas A&M if very similar to a SEC school. Texas A&M has the tradition in fanaticism of a SEC school which would endear them to the rest of the conference. The problem with Texas A&M is that their own field performance has been horrible in the past ten years. Before the turn of the century Texas A&M was a team right there in the thick of things in the top 25, not so much lately. The biggest problem with Texas and Texas A&M joining the SEC is geography. Maybe having Texas would offset the traveling expenses with the increased revenue. Another side benefit to adding Texas and Texas A&M would be the renewal of the old Southwest Conference rivalries between the two Texas schools and Arkansas.
From a competitive stand point Oklahoma and Texas would be a better fit. Oklahoma brings a solid football program and top notch teams in all the other major college sports. This would also be an easy way to keep the red river rivalry alive. Once again geography is a problem.
More realisticly, Florida State and Miami would work out logistically. FSU and Miami do not bring the financial perks to the conference but they do keep things regional. The one hinderence would be the FSU chickened out in the 90’s becuase they did not want to play Auburn and Alabama every year. I am not sure if this is an issue anymore but it maybe. There is an easy rode through the ACC than there is through the SEC. Although, I am not sure going undefeated in a weak ACC gets you into the BCS title game. A one loss SEC champion would have a better shot at it. However, it would be nice for the three big Florida schools who have more a less dominated college football for the last 25 years have to play each other every year now. This may not be a selling point to Florida.
The other option would be trading Clemson for Miami and bringing in Clemson and FSU. Clemson would fit better in the SEC because there is more tradition and the fans are very similar to SEC fans. Competively Clemson does not bring much other than they are much better than Vanderbilt or Miss. State.
Louisville would be an okay fit. The problem with Louisville is their football program is inconsistent. While their basketball program would help the SEC’s RPI they would need to stabilize their football program. Maybe they could be a provisional member based on geography.
South Florida is an up and comer in D1 athletics and has proved they can play with the big schools. South Florida is in the middle of a recruting hot bed so they could potentially be a player for a long time. The university has proven that it is dedicate to having a competitive D1 football program so they would fit in the respect. I am not sure how the rest of their sports programs would fit in. USF may not like being in the same division with Florida because they would never have a home game. I think every time the Gators played in Raymond James stadium there would be more orange and blue than green and gold.
Texas makes the most sense from a financial perspective but I just don’t see it happening. If the SEC cannot get Texas they should at least upgrade the competition in the conference.
Someone else will have to figure out how to realign the divisions.